Medical journal review sample Overall it is a good, well-‐written article with an important message for public administrators and organizations. It is dedicated to promoting the scientific achievements of medical students, teaching principles of peer and article review, and providing editorial, publishing and leadership learning experiences. A Journal Review Form is an essential tool for evaluating the quality, relevance, and structure of academic articles. The task of writing a scientific review article can seem overwhelming; however, it can be managed by using an organized approach and devoting sufficient time to the process. Sample outline Summary of the research and your overall impression In your own words, summarize the main research question, claims, and conclusions of the study. doi:10. As a result, some may forgo opportunities to provide valuable and highly insightful feedback on research publi-cations. Comments on how the report fits in the state of current knowledge on the topic. If you are an author or want to be an author, you have a duty to take part in reviewing your colleagues When you write a peer review for a manuscript, what should you include in your comments? What should you leave out? And how should the review be formatted? Submitting a medical literature review to a scholarly journal is the final step in the literature review process. 2015. Review Article Template We offer this template to assist all authors of Review Articles (both systematic and narrative) being submitted to the Journal of Osteopathic Medicine in preparing their work for efficient peer review. These sample papers formatted in seventh edition APA Style show the format that authors should use to submit a manuscript for publication in a professional journal and that students should use to submit a paper to an instructor for a course assignment. It is an Open Access platform to support scientific innovation and advancement in the research community by increasing access to peer-reviewed quality research articles. Dec 6, 2023 · A narrative review on burnout experienced by medical students and residents (Dyrbye & Shanafelt, 2015) – read here 2. HCA Healthcare Journal of Medicine Among the pillars of science is the galvanizing process of peer review. The following information should not be included in the main manuscript file, but should instead be uploaded as part of the covering letter: Title page Competing interests Authors’ contributions Acknowledgements Authors’ information WHAT IS A CLINICAL CASE REPORT? A case report is a detailed report of the symptoms, signs, diagnosis, treatment, and follow-up of an individual patient. Here, we would like to offer some insights on how to craft a comprehensive and authoritative assessment of a field. 1016/j. Learn how to write a comprehensive and insightful medical literature review with our in-depth guide. Although some journals are highly specific about how reviewers should struc-ture their feedback, many publications— including top- tier medical journals—assume that all reviewers will know how to construct responses. Table 1. Sample Format For Reviewing A Journal Article Reading and summarizing a research article in the behavioral or medical sciences can be overwhelming. Bhui, Rabeea'h W. Some reports contain an extensive review of the relevant literature on the . Some programs do not use powerpoints or want your presentation under 5 mins. 02. A well-written review not only benefits the author of the article under scrutiny but also serves as a valuable resource Dec 14, 2024 · This article highlights an example of a journal critique, illustrating how to assess the research findings's validity and the robustness of conclusions. Peer review template for patients and other novice reviewers Sample Peer-Review of a Fictitious Manuscript Reviewer A’s Comments to Authors: This is a prospective study that analyzed the factors associated with cancer progression after EMR of Barrett’s esophagus with high-grade dysplasia. Aslam, et al. A literature review can be an informative, critical, and useful synthesis of a particular topic. In the medical sciences, the importance of review articles is rising. Journals for other fields of healthcare can be Apr 5, 2021 · Here I share my experience publishing scientific papers including example peer review comments and how to address them. We have previously discussed peer review generally (Why do the rules and conventions of academic publishing keep changing and how can researchers stay current?) and how authors can effectively respond to peer review (Writing effective response letters Here you can find an overview of sample comments and examples for the most common review decisions: ‘minor revisions’, ‘major revisions’, ‘revise and resubmit’ and ‘reject’ decisions. MR publishes high-quality internationally competitive review articles on cutting-edge progress and achievement from various areas of medical science, specifically focuses The system of peer-reviewed journals requires that academics review papers written by other academics, that is, papers written by their peers. While the information here is generally applicable to all journals with standard peer review practices, it’s important to ensure that you take into account any specific instructions given by the particular journal you are reviewing for. A well-written review article must summarize key research findings, reference must-read articles Oct 12, 2020 · Too many choices of where to submit your paper to for publication? Here are the most prestigious medical journals for scientists and doctors to publish in. The British Journal of Psychiatry Aug 2015, 207 (2) 95-103. Citations may include links to full text content from PubMed Central and publisher web sites. Editors of medical and scientific publications recruit specialty leaders to evaluate the quality of manuscripts. Eighty patients underwent EMR and were followed every 3 months for 1 year, and every 6 months thereafter for 3 years. When clinicians want to update their knowledge and generate guidelines about a topic, they frequently use reviews as a starting point. Make sure to ask the residents how they usually do journal club in their department. Provide a brief summary of the review question being addressed or rationale for the review, the major studies reviewed, and conclusions drawn. This article lists academic journals that focus on the practice of medicine or any medical specialty. 010 Please note: Journal of Patient-Reported Outcomes operates double-blind peer review. Nov 13, 2025 · This review describes the current management of type B aortic dissection, including medical therapy and thoracic endovascular aortic repair. It is imperfect, to be sure, but there is widespread agreement that it is the best way to ensure that reliable scientific information is published. Jan 8, 2025 · Discover the top 10 medical journals by impact factor and influence, which hold a unique position in the global medical community. 1 – 4 Being a reviewer is only 1 component of the process of publication. Evidence-based medicine forms the essence of medical practice in the modern world. Comments on the appropriateness of the paper for this journal. The medical journals usually notify reviewers of the ultimate decision to accept or reject a manuscript and allow them to share the review of co-reviewer (s) of the same paper so that they learn from each other in the review process. The article gives an interesting historical and scientific perspective on a field that has only recently boomed. Comments on the importance, impact or action related to the study. ijnurstu. Introduction: Introduce the topic and your rationale for addressing this topic focusing on why this topic is important. May 22, 2025 · The American Journal of Medicine - "The Green Journal" - publishes original clinical research of interest to physicians in internal medicine, both in academia and community-based practice. Journals may require reviewers to copy and paste responses from the template into a journal website or upload a clean copy of the template as an attachment. Please do not cite references in the Abstract. AJM is the official journal of the Alliance for Academic Internal Medicine Opens in new window , a prestigious group comprising internal medicine department chairs at more than 125 medical schools across the A guide to writing commentaries and editorials for medical journals. It critiques Lieff's arguments for lacking empirical support and suggests that significant changes in medical Abstract: An abstract should be of approximately 200-300 words. Review articles present comprehensive overview of relevant literature on specific themes and synthesise the studies related to these themes, with the aim of strengthening the foundation of knowledge and facilitating theory development. Journals are listed alphabetically by journal name, and also grouped by the subfield of medicine they focus on. Clearly define exactly PubMed® comprises more than 39 million citations for biomedical literature from MEDLINE, life science journals, and online books. [citation for the study your journal club is focused on] Questions to Consider for your Presentation: Background & Overview What are the current guideline recommendations for this particular disease state or topic? An article review is a critical evaluation of a scholarly or scientific piece, which aims to summarize its main ideas, assess its contributions, and provide constructive feedback. Jan 28, 2025 · Discover the 50 best medical journals for physicians by specialty. Reviewing a Journal Article (Peer Review) Peer-review is defined as the expert assessment of submitted materials. Nov 6, 2025 · Medical Student Research Journal A journal authored, reviewed, edited, and published by medical students for medical students. The value of a review is associated with Explore the index of articles published by the New England Journal of Medicine, from original research to videos in clinical medicine and more. Our step-by-step guide to conducting a review will help you through the processes of reviewing the paper, structuring your report, providing criticisms and recommendations. Review Articles make a different sort of contribution to science (McMillan, 2001, 3, emphasis added): In contrast to research papers, conference presentations, and proposals, a review paper is a journal article that synthesizes work by many independent researchers on a particular subject or scientific problem. Free Resource: List of the Best Academic Journals for Publishing Biomedical, Psychology, Psychopathy, Oncology, Nov 11, 2024 · Review articles are our bread and butter. Systematic review - identifies and critically appraises all research on a specific topic, and combines valid studies; increasingly important in evidence based medicine; different from review article (which is a summary of more than one paper on a specific topic, and which may or may not be comprehensive); Dec 27, 2022 · Preparing Your Study, Review, or Article for Publication in Medical Journals The majority of social, behavioral, biological, and clinical journals follow the conventional structured abstract form with the following four major headings (or variations of these headings): Professional Review Committee (PRC): The Medical Staff committee or department that administers continuous improvement of quality of care through the ongoing monitoring and review of Medical Staff and Allied Health practitioner performance. Whether you’re a student, professor, or researcher, mastering the Review Form process is crucial to Peer review of a review article Gustavo Gutierrez Gonzalez says: Hydbring and Badalian-Very summarize in this review, the current status in the potential development of clinical applications based on miRNAs’ biology. These peer reviewers help to ensure that data are collected, analyzed, and interpreted as accurately as possible, thereby moving the field forward and ultimately improving Nov 14, 2025 · Contains resources about literature reviews and how to write them, including journal articles, eBooks, and databases. It can identify what is known (and unknown) in the subject area, identify areas of controversy or debate, and help formulate questions that need further research. They combine long-standing editorial traditions with strict review standards and consistently publish practice-changing clinical trials, major public health studies, and high-impact translational research. Discuss the manuscript’s strengths and weaknesses and your overall recommendation. ASHP New Practitioners Forum ASHP is not responsible for, and does not officially endorse this expressly by the References: 1. It involves a detailed and comprehensive plan and search strategy derived from a set of specified research Guarantor: It is becoming increasingly common for medical journals to ask that one of the authors be named as the “guarantor”, as in the person who takes responsibility for the integrity and accuracy of the report. For many kinds of assignments, like a literature review, you may be asked to offer a critique or review of a journal article. The reviews by Pettenuzzo and Fan, 19 Varekojis, 20 and Davis and Smallwood 21 are examples of well-written reviews. Medical journals are published regularly to communicate new research to clinicians, medical scientists, and other healthcare workers. Provide context for how this research fits within the existing literature. No wonder review articles are the mainstay for evidence-based medicine. Note: If uploading the review as an attachment, remember to remove the template examples and writing prompts. Below is a simple model to guide students through this process. This guide covers how to use a Journal Form to critically assess research, ensuring that key elements like methodology, analysis, and conclusions are thoroughly reviewed. The process involves selecting a topic about which the authors are knowledgeable and Oct 23, 2025 · Explains the standard parts of a medical research article, compares characteristics of types of journals, and shows how to find peer reviewed articles and journals. The duties of this committee/department are outlined in the Medical Staff Bylaws. Because ‘‘the goal of this process is to ensure that the valid article is accepted, the messy article improved, and the invalid article rejected,’’ It is done voluntarily and without compensation. Typically, you are asked to present an article while on an AI or visiting rotation. This is an opportunity for you as a scholar to offer your qualified opinion and evaluation of how another scholar has composed their article, argument, and research. With research accelerating at an unprecedented speed in recent years and more and more original papers being published, review articles have become increasingly important as a means to keep up to date with developments in a particular area of research. Aug 1, 2021 · PDF | On Aug 1, 2021, Liz Salmi and others published A step-by-step guide to peer review: a template for patients and novice reviewers | Find, read and cite all the research you need on ResearchGate JSciMed Central publishes international, peer-reviewed science, medicine, and engineering journals. How To Review a Journal Article Mary Anne Jackson, MD Professor of Pediatrics, UMKC SOM Angela Myers, MD, MPH Professor of Pediatrics, UMKC SOM Children’s Mercy Hospital Apr 5, 2018 · Peer review is an essential component of the scientific process. There are several commonly used formats for literature reviews, including systematic reviews conducted as primary research projects Nov 7, 2025 · Guide to research sources and tools for locating health evidence in books, journals, databases. Was the sample of patients appropriate to the question at hand and representative of patients with this problem? Consider: Different forms of identifying the cohort may carry different biases. Review articles provide a critical summary of the existing literature to explain the current state of scientific evidence on a particular topic. Jun 19, 2020 · 50+ Top Medical Journals for FAST Publication. Oct 20, 2021 · Objective CN: CN 10-1793/R On-line ISSN: 2749-9642 Print ISSN: 2097-0733 (applies for copies in China) Medical Review（MR） is a peer-reviewed, open-access journal affiliated with Peking University Health Science Center . International Journal Of Nursing Studies, 521107-1120. A good review article provides readers with an in-depth The document is a literature review focusing on Jonathan Lieff's 1982 article that discusses the prejudicial attitudes of American doctors towards elderly and terminally ill patients, emphasizing the need for addressing psychological and spiritual considerations in medical training. Case reports usually describe an unusual or novel occurrence and as such, remain one of the cornerstones of medical progress and provide many new ideas in medicine. Feb 8, 2022 · REVIEW EXAMPLE REQUIRING FURTHER ELABORATION Mission Statement WestJEM focuses on how the systems and delivery of emergency care affects health, health disparities, and health outcomes in communities and populations worldwide, including the impact of social conditions on the composition of patients seeking care in emergency departments. Nov 10, 2025 · Review: Patient participation in nursing care on medical wards: An integrative review. Oct 8, 2024 · We look at the top medical journals in the world and why health writers prefer to use their published articles for their writing. Stay updated on clinical research, advancements, and trends across 10 major disciplines. . Systematic Review Examples This type of literature review is more structured and rigorous than a narrative review. The piece, when taken as a May 12, 2023 · Abstract Scientific review articles are comprehensive, focused reviews of the scientific literature written by subject matter experts. The Once the reader gets to the really good examples that are relevant to the everyday life of a public administrator, a good portion of the article has already past. Res Medica Interventions to improve therapeutic communications between Black and minority ethnic patients and professionals in psychiatric services: systematic review Kamaldeep S. Abstract Literature reviews are valuable resources for the scientific community. Regardless of the timing and format, every journal The New England Journal of Medicine (NEJM) is a weekly general medical journal that publishes new medical research and review articles, and editorial opinion on a wide variety of topics of The purpose of this guide is to give a practical introduction to conducting effective peer reviews, especially for those who are new to the process. mnx bkoshy wrwcf gytg thf ahmzlwl lifmp wfht vbvzog ndpn wuv tlynwx jndqkd dolalj iiugjw